Both decide who inherits. They differ in what happens between your death and that inheritance actually arriving. Three questions usually settle it.
They answer different questions
A will says who gets what, and who raises your children. A living trust says the same things
— and also holds the assets, so they can be handed over without a court involved. Choosing
between them is less about what you own than about what you want the process to look like.
Question one: do you own real property in California?
This is the one that decides it for most people. A house in your own name goes through probate,
and California's probate fees are calculated on its gross value before the mortgage. If you own a
home here, a trust usually pays for itself several times over.
Question two: do you mind it being public?
Probate files are public records. The inventory, the valuations, the beneficiaries and their
shares are all readable by anyone. A trust administration is private — nothing is filed,
nothing is published.
Question three: who would be managing it?
Probate puts a court timetable between your family and your estate. A successor trustee can act
immediately. If the person who would be sorting out your affairs lives out of state, has a job
they cannot leave, or simply would not cope with a year of court deadlines, that matters more than
the fee comparison.
What a trust does not replace
A living trust still needs a pour-over will alongside it, as a safety net for
anything never transferred in. And a will is the only place you can nominate a guardian for minor
children — a trust cannot do that. Anyone with children under eighteen needs a will whether
or not they also have a trust.
Neither one covers you while you are alive
Both documents only operate after death. If you are alive but cannot make decisions, your family
needs a durable power of attorney for finances and an advance health care
directive for medical choices. Without them the route is conservatorship — a court
process, public, and more expensive than probate.
A reasonable rule of thumb
- No real property, modest assets, children under 18 — a will plus powers
of attorney usually covers it.
- A home in California — a living trust, with a pour-over will behind it.
- Either way — powers of attorney and a health care directive, which cost
the least and get used the most.
This article is general information about California law, not legal advice about your
situation. My Wise Legacy is a document preparation service and not a law firm.